Independent film criticism — 31 reviews and counting Film index A–Z  ·  Contact  ·  Editorial policy

Comedy films, reviewed

Comedy is the hardest genre to write about, because explaining a joke is the surest way to kill it, and the hardest to sustain, because a film must be funny across ninety minutes rather than in a sketch. The comedies worth taking seriously are the ones with a consistent comic logic — a world with its own rules — and something underneath the jokes that justifies the runtime.

What we look for in comedy

  • A consistent comic logic rather than isolated gags
  • Performers with real timing rather than good material alone
  • Something underneath the humour that earns the length
  • Tonal control — knowing when not to be funny

This hub currently collects 4 reviews. Our library is curated rather than comprehensive, and every genre page grows as we publish.

Every comedy film we have reviewed

Ordered by our score, highest first.

  • Parasite (2019) review cover art — thriller film directed by Bong Joon-ho 96

    2019 · Thriller

    Parasite review

    A poor family infiltrates a rich household, and the film turns into something else entirely. The staircase motif is not decoration — it is the thesis.

    ★★★★★ 5.0/5

  • Toy Story (1995) review cover art — animation film directed by John Lasseter 93

    1995 · Animation

    Toy Story review

    A cowboy doll and a space ranger learn to share a boy's affection. The first fully computer-animated feature and still one of the best-written.

    ★★★★½ 4.8/5

  • Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022) review cover art — sci-fi film directed by Daniel Kwan, Daniel Scheinert 92

    2022 · Sci-Fi

    Everything Everywhere All at Once review

    A laundromat owner discovers she must connect with parallel versions of herself to save existence, and the film turns out to be about a mother and a d…

    ★★★★½ 4.7/5

  • The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014) review cover art — comedy film directed by Wes Anderson 91

    2014 · Comedy

    The Grand Budapest Hotel review

    A legendary concierge and his lobby boy navigate a stolen painting, a family fortune, and the collapse of Europe. Anderson's funniest and saddest film…

    ★★★★½ 4.7/5

Comedy index

Year, director, runtime and score for every film in this genre.

FilmYearDirectorRuntimeScoreRating
Parasite 2019Bong Joon-ho132 min 96★★★★★
Toy Story 1995John Lasseter81 min 93★★★★½
Everything Everywhere All at Once 2022Daniel Kwan, Daniel Scheinert139 min 92★★★★½
The Grand Budapest Hotel 2014Wes Anderson99 min 91★★★★½

Frequently asked questions

What makes a comedy last beyond its moment?

A world with its own internal rules, and a subject underneath the jokes. Jokes date; comic logic and character do not.

Why is comedy so rarely rewarded at awards ceremonies?

Because laughter is difficult to evaluate in a way that feels serious, and because comic performances are frequently underrated as technical achievements. Timing is a craft.

Which comedy here has the most serious subject?

The Grand Budapest Hotel, which is genuinely funny throughout and ends as an elegy for a vanished Europe.

Read around comedy

Our ranked lists place these films against each other within a decade or a genre, and explain the ordering.

Browse all 31 reviews See ranked lists